The Delhi Police has argued before the Supreme Court that social media content creators who make reels cannot automatically claim the same legal protections as professional journalists. The issue relates to allegations of police obstruction during protests against the Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) at Jantar Mantar, Delhi.

We are journalists

Why in the News?

The Delhi Police submitted an affidavit before the Supreme Court distinguishing professional journalists from social media content creators or reel-makers.

  • The affidavit was filed in response to petitions by:
    • Network of Women in Media.
    • Free Speech Collective.
    • Delhi Union of Journalists.
    • Kerala Union of Working Journalists.

The petitions alleged that journalists were obstructed while covering protests against the Chief Election Commissioner at Jantar Mantar.

  • On October 11, 2026, the Supreme Court directed that lawyers, journalists and other professionals should not be hindered while performing their duties.

Key Arguments of Delhi Police

The Delhi Police stated that professional journalists and social media content creators are different categories. The police also clarified that individuals making and uploading reels are free to do so, but they cannot automatically claim the protections available to professional journalists.

  • Journalists: They perform professional duties of gathering, recording and reporting information.
  • Reel-makers: They create social media content, often for commercial purposes and monetisation.
  • The police argued that merely carrying a camera and microphone does not automatically make someone a journalist.
  • It stated that the distinction between journalism and content creation should be examined on the basis of the intention behind the activity.

Delhi Police's Position on Allegations of Obstruction

The police denied deliberately obstructing journalists during the protests. It stated that journalists from national, international, regional, accredited and unaccredited media organisations were allowed to cover the protests. The police also stated that individuals carrying cameras were sometimes asked to maintain a reasonable distance from operational areas to avoid interfering with law-enforcement activities.

  • It cited media coverage by organisations such as BBC, The Indian Express, The Quint and Brut India.
  • Any interference, if it occurred, was described as inadvertent and due to mistaken identity or crowd-control requirements.
  • Individuals apprehended due to mistaken identity were released after verification.
  • The police maintained that some individuals claiming to be journalists were actually participating in protests and raising slogans.

Guidelines for Journalists Issued by Delhi Police

On October 5, 2026, Delhi Police issued guidelines for journalists through social media platforms. The police described these measures as facilitative and precautionary, aimed at identifying genuine journalists and ensuring their safety. Major provisions:

  • Journalists must carry valid identity cards.
  • Identity cards should be visibly displayed at all times.
  • Journalists must not obstruct police operations.
  • They should maintain a reasonable and safe distance from sensitive operational areas.
  • PIB accreditation is not compulsory for identification.
  • Identity cards issued by respective media organisations can also be accepted.

Constitutional Provisions Involved

Article 19(1)(a): Freedom of Speech and Expression

  • Guarantees all citizens the right to freedom of speech and expression.
  • Freedom of the press is recognised as an important part of this fundamental right.
  • It protects the right of journalists to gather, record and disseminate information.

Article 19(2): Reasonable Restrictions

  • Allows the State to impose reasonable restrictions on freedom of speech and expression.
  • Restrictions can be imposed on grounds such as public order, security of the State, and sovereignty and integrity of India.

Working Journalist: Legal Framework

The Delhi Police referred to the definition of a working journalist under the Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020. It argued that the term has a specific meaning in the digital era.

  • The affidavit highlighted journalist accreditation guidelines as a possible basis for distinguishing professional journalists from content creators.

Key Issues Involved

  1. Press Freedom: Ensuring that journalists can report protests without unnecessary interference.
  2. Identification of Journalists: Establishing a clear method to distinguish professional journalists from content creators.
  3. Social Media and Journalism: Determining whether social media content creators performing reporting activities should receive similar protections.
  4. Public Order: Balancing press freedom with the need to maintain law and order during protests.
  5. Digital Media Regulation: Addressing the changing nature of journalism in the digital age.

Conclusion

The issue highlights the growing challenge of distinguishing professional journalism from social media content creation in the digital era. While freedom of the press is an important part of Article 19(1)(a), the matter also raises questions about journalist identification, public order, and the scope of press protections. The Supreme Court consideration of these issues may have implications for journalism and media freedom in India.