The Supreme Court of India is facing a serious backlog of cases, which has affected its ability to focus on important constitutional matters. A proposed solution is to separate its functions into a Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal. This could improve judicial efficiency, reduce delays and ensure faster justice.

Why in the News?

The need to restructure the Supreme Court of India has gained attention due to its increasing case pendency and declining focus on constitutional matters. The objective is to reduce the Supreme Court's workload and improve access to justice. The proposed reform involves establishing:

  • A Constitutional Court in Delhi to hear constitutional cases and substantial questions of law.
  • Four or five regional Courts of Appeal to handle ordinary appeals.

Background: Increasing Pendency in the Supreme Court

At the end of 2025, the Supreme Court had 92,318 pending cases, its highest backlog ever. The pendency increased by nearly 10,000 cases compared to the previous year.

  • The court's workload is increasingly dominated by ordinary appeals instead of important constitutional matters.

Declining Constitutional Work

During the first half of the 1960s, Constitution Benches decided an average of 134 cases annually. Over the last decade, this number declined to fewer than 10 cases annually.

  • This has reduced the court's ability to focus on important constitutional questions.

Growing Burden of Special Leave Petitions (SLPs)

Under Article 136, the Supreme Court has discretionary power to grant Special Leave to Appeal against decisions of courts and tribunals. SLPs were intended to serve as an exceptional remedy.

  • However, they have become a major part of the Supreme Court workload.
  • In 2011, SLPs accounted for 84.6% of the court's admission docket.

Supreme Court's Position

In Bihar Legal Support Society (1986), a Constitution Bench led by Chief Justice P.N. Bhagwati observed that the Supreme Court was never intended to function as an ordinary court of appeal.

Proposed Reform: Two-Tier Judicial Structure

The proposed reform aims to separate constitutional matters from ordinary appeals.

Proposed InstitutionMain Functions
Constitutional CourtAround 11 judges in Delhi to hear constitutional cases and substantial questions of law.
Regional Courts of AppealFour or five regional courts to handle ordinary appeals and reduce the burden on the Constitutional Court.

Need for Dividing the Supreme Court

1. Reduction in Case Pendency

The Supreme Court's workload has increased beyond its existing capacity.

  • Merely increasing the number of judges may not solve the problem.
  • Separating constitutional matters from ordinary appeals can improve case management.

2. Specialisation in Constitutional Matters

A dedicated Constitutional Court can focus on important constitutional questions.

  • It can deliver consistent and predictable judgments.
  • It can help settle major legal issues through detailed hearings.

3. Faster Justice for Ordinary Litigants

Regional Courts of Appeal can handle ordinary cases more efficiently. They can bring appellate justice closer to citizens.

  • This can reduce the need for litigants to approach the Supreme Court in Delhi for ordinary appeals.

4. Better Use of Judicial Resources

Constitutional matters and ordinary appeals require different approaches. Separate institutions can improve judicial specialisation and efficiency.

  • This would allow the Constitutional Court to focus on its core constitutional responsibilities.

Recommendations for Judicial Reforms in India

1. 229th Law Commission Report (2009)

  • Recommended establishing a Constitution Bench in Delhi.
  • Proposed creating four regional Cassation Benches to deal with appellate matters.

2. Parliamentary Standing Committee (2023)

  • Recommended establishing regional Benches of the Supreme Court.
  • The Union Law Ministry has accepted the recommendation.

3. Article 130 of the Constitution

Article 130 deals with the seat of the Supreme Court. The 229th Law Commission Report suggested that this provision may allow the establishment of regional Benches without a constitutional amendment.

  • This could enable the Supreme Court to take the first steps towards reform without waiting for Parliamentary approval.

International Models of Judicial Structure

Several countries follow a two-tier or specialised judicial structure.

CountryJudicial Structure
United StatesThe U.S. Supreme Court functions above 13 federal Courts of Appeals and hears only a small proportion of cases.
South AfricaHas a Constitutional Court in Johannesburg and a separate Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein.
GermanyThe Federal Constitutional Court in Karlsruhe deals with constitutional matters, while specialised federal courts handle other areas of law.
BrazilThe 1988 Constitution created a separate Superior Tribunal of Justice to handle ordinary federal appellate matters, reducing the dual burden on the Supreme Federal Tribunal.

Lessons from Brazil and the United States

These examples show that judicial restructuring must be supported by an effective system for filtering cases.

  • Brazil: The creation of a separate appellate court did not automatically reduce pendency. Improvement came after the apex court received the power to filter cases.
  • United States: The Supreme Court receives around 7,000 petitions annually but grants review to roughly 1% of them.
  • Brazil: Following a 2004 reform, the apex court hears a constitutional appeal only when the issue has a wider impact beyond the parties involved. This principle is known as General Repercussion.

Challenges and Concerns

1. Risk of Weakening the Supreme Court's Authority

Successive Chief Justices have expressed concerns about dividing the Supreme Court. Regional Courts of Appeal may be viewed as lower-level institutions compared to the Constitutional Court in Delhi.

  • Litigants may continue trying to approach the apex court, creating additional pressure on the new structure.

2. Loss of Institutional Unity

  • The Supreme Court's authority partly comes from being the final court of appeal.
  • Dividing its functions may weaken the perception of a single and unified apex court.

3. Risk of Continued Pendency

  • Simply creating a separate Constitutional Court may not solve the backlog.
  • Without the power to filter cases, the new court may also become overcrowded.

4. Need for Effective Case Selection

  • A clear mechanism is needed to identify cases involving important constitutional questions.
  • Only cases involving substantial legal or constitutional significance should reach the Constitutional Court.

Increase in the Supreme Court's Sanctioned Strength

In 2019, the sanctioned strength of the Supreme Court was increased to 34 judges. At that time, pending cases stood at around 60,000. Despite the increase in judicial strength, the pendency continued to rise. This indicates that increasing the number of judges alone may not be sufficient. Structural reforms are also needed.

  • In 2025:
    • The court disposed of 65,615 cases.
    • It received 75,410 fresh cases.
  • In 2026, Parliament increased the sanctioned strength again to 38 judges.

Conclusion

The growing pendency of cases has affected the Supreme Court's ability to perform its core constitutional role. Establishing a dedicated Constitutional Court and regional Courts of Appeal could improve specialisation, reduce delays and bring justice closer to citizens. However, this reform must be supported by an effective case-filtering system and safeguards to maintain the authority of the apex court. The objective should be to strengthen the judiciary, not weaken its institutional unity.